[ Green Books ] [ Horizontal Rule ]
[ Horizontal Rule ]
[an error occurred while processing this directive]
[ Green Books ]
[ Green Books - Exploring the Words and Worlds of J.R.R. Tolkien ] [ Green Books ]

"On the Wings of a Revisionist" - Murray B.

Every Tolkien fan knows these controversial words,

        "...suddenly it drew itself up to a great height, and its wings were spread from wall to wall..." (p. 433, vol. I , 1999 HarperCollins paperback edition)

So far most participants in this debate about the wings have assumed that the statement is always ambiguous but this not correct.  It is only ambiguous when the balrog is presumed to have wings.

To illustrate this, two related passages are shown side by side instead of with their normal separation of a few sentences.

        "His enemy halted again, facing him, and the shadow about it reached out like two vast wings ... suddenly it drew itself up to a great height, and its wings were spread from wall to wall."

If we presume that the balrog has no wings then the statement is clear and unambiguous.  The wings are the shadow which had "spread from wall to wall". 

It is when the balrog is presumed to have wings and the second part is taken out of context and compared to the rest of the text that the ambiguity appears. Only then is it unclear as to whether the word "wings" refers to real wings or to the shadow.

At first it appears that there is no rational way to resolve the issue, but this is not the case. It is the ambiguity itself that decides the issue.

Besides being a great author, J.R.R. Tolkien was also an English professor.  If there are wings on the balrog then Professor Tolkien has published a work containing the sophomoric error of an obviously ambiguous statement. It is impossible to believe that the author, his peers, editors, and fans would have continually missed this error for the nearly two decades between the publication of the book in 1954 and the author's passing in 1973. There can be no ambiguity and this leaves the unambiguous version as the only reasonable interpretation.  It follows that balrogs do not and have never had wings.

Now for the real mystery; Why have these servants of Melkor been so successful at blaming Tolkien's writing for  their own poor reading?   It is time for all true Tolkienists to rise up to "hew the stone and break the door" (p. 100, vol. II) of these servants of darkness.  Who will be in the van?

Murray B.

[ Email this Page to a Friend ] Email this page to a friend!


Current Article(s)
The Science of Middle-earth: Something Wicked This Way Comes

Past Guests
The Science of Middle-earth: The Great Wave
The Science of Middle-earth: Sex and the Single Orc
The Science of Middle-earth: The Kine of Araw
A Postscript on the Nine Walkers
The Science of Middle-earth: Melanism and Middle-earth<
Hearing the horns of Rohan
The Eternal Conflict in Middle-earth: from Literature to Film
The Science of Middle-earth -- How High the Mallorn?
Lost in Translation? The Lord of the Rings in Russian
The Science of Middle-earth -- O, for the Wings of a Balrog
Myth, Judgement, and the Jackson Way: The Review of Reviews
The Science of Middle-earth -- The Laboratory of Fëanor
What Tolkien Saw: Part Two -- Truth, Glory and Applicability
What Tolkien Saw: Part One -- Entropy, Hubris, and Hope
The Science of Middle-earth -- Making Mithril
"There and Back Again" -- A Survivor's Story
The Science of Middle-earth -- Hawk-Flights of Imagination
Power in the Name
The Science of Middle-earth -- Keen are the Eyes of the Elves
The Science of Middle-earth -- An Ongoing Series
The Enemy is Moving...and He is Us
Q&A with Verlyn Flieger
Beowulf Lives! Or Why Would a Nice Professor Like Tolkien Tell Stories about Nasty Monsters
- Christopher Garbowski
The Tolkien Effect: using the work of J.R.R. Tolkien to inspire children to read
- Annie White Owl
How Much Was Rowling Inspired by Tolkien?
- Caroline Monroe
"On the Wings of a Revisionist"
- Murray B.
JRR Tolkien and World War I
- Nancy Marie Ott
Lord of the Rings: Fellowship of the Ring Movie Review
- Rajesh Shah
Lord of the Rings: Fellowship of the Ring Movie Review
- Chris Peters
Spiritual Lessons in 'Lord of the Rings'
- Kevin Black
"The Lord of the Rings" — An Archetypal Hero’s Journey
- Jody G. Bower
Mythcon 32 and Meeting Philippa Boyens
- Thomas Kelley
Scrolls of Middle-earth
- Lute
Every Time A Bell Rings A Balrog Gets Its Wings?
- William Roper
That 70s Show: Tolkien Art Style
- Vastarion
Who is Tom Bombadil?
- Edoardo Albert
Where the Shadows Lie
- Kevin Roger Black
Macho Men & Warrior Princesses
- Kara Gardner
Growing Up
- Éomer
Tolkien's Greatest Sleepers
- Turumarth
Arwen's Defense
- Lúthien
The Future of the Nine Walkers
- J.W. Braun
Special Guest Home


In Association with Amazon.com

home | contact us | back to top | site map |search | join list | review this site

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, and related properties mentioned herein are held by their respective owners and are used solely for promotional purposes of said properties. Design and original photography however are copyright © 2000 TheOneRing.net ™.